Home Elevator vs. Stair Lift

home elevator living room

Many homes have more than one level, and most of them require climbing up and down the stairs to access those levels. Unfortunately, not everyone can manage this movement. Whether your home includes someone in a wheelchair or you have an aging parent who has difficulty navigating stairs on their own, you need an alternative to assist your loved one with moving from floor to floor.

The good news is, you have options. Home elevators and stair lifts both provide vital assistance to people who cannot climb stairs. Which one offers a better fit for your household? Let’s explore the possibilities.

Pros of a Home Elevator

 

  • Flexible installation spots throughout your home
  • Complete configuration and design customization
  • Safest and most improved home mobility
  • Increase in home value

Home elevators have many things going for them. In addition to being easy to use for someone in a wheelchair or with difficulty walking, they can take on whatever decor you desire and make it faster to get to higher floors in the home if you have more than one floor.

More than one person can use an elevator at the same time, making them a more practical investment than a stair lift, which serves only one individual at a time. Here are some of the biggest advantages of choosing a home elevator over a stair lift.

1. Flexible Installation Locations

You can put your home elevator practically anywhere in the house — you’re not limited to a single area. Imagine the possibilities. You could have the elevator in the back of your home, where guests can’t see it, or make it the focal point of the entryway. You may decide to place it near the bedroom of the person who most needs its services. Stair lifts, by contrast, can only be placed in one area of the home — on the stairs.

2. Customizable Configuration and Design

You can customize the design of your elevator to meet your decor preferences. Do you love modern? Traditional? Even something with a little country flair is fair game when you get to pick the design. You’ll even have options for the configuration that powers your system, such as:

  • Cable drum
  • MRL overhead cable drum
  • Hydraulic

3. Safe and Improved Home Mobility

Elevators give those with limited mobility a chance to do things independently. They can get into and out of the elevator by themselves, unlike with a stair lift, where they may require assistance. Elevators are safe spaces, too. Handrails give people something to lean on. They don’t have to balance in a moving chair that could stop or start unexpectedly. With an elevator, they can take control of their movement — a quality that’s always appreciated.

4. Increases Home Resale Value

Home improvements often increase the resale value of a home. An elevator is an especially valuable addition because it makes the house accessible to more people. When you pay for an elevator in your home, you’re making an investment in the future. Not only will the resale value of your home rise, but you’ll also attract more people interested in your house because of that versatility.

Cons of Stair Lifts

 

  • Difficult to conceal and sticks out in your home’s design
  • Limited to no customization to match your home
  • Does not add to home resale value
  • Bulky equipment that takes up staircase space

Stair lifts provide another option for helping those with limited mobility get around the house. Unlike with elevators, stair lifts have a lot of drawbacks. Their limited range and the fact that only one person can use them at a time are serious disadvantages to adding a stair lift to a property. Here are some of the other cons of installing a stair lift.

Difficult to Conceal

When you install a stair lift, everyone can see it, and it’s not the most attractive addition. There’s no cover or drape that you can put over it. When you have company over, they’ll see the stair lift sitting on the staircase — little can be done about that.

Few Design Options

With an elevator, you can choose the cab style, the way it’s designed and what types of materials are used. When you get a stair lift, you get next to no choices. All chair lifts have the same design. You may not even have a choice in the color, depending on where you get your lift. Since the lift needs to be sturdy enough to get someone from top to bottom, it also has to be strong, which can result in clunky designs.

Does Not Increase Home Resale Value

Stair lifts are not a highly desirable feature in a home, so they won’t raise the resale price of your house. You won’t get back the money you put into installing the stair lift. In fact, you may even limit the pool of potential buyers. If someone doesn’t want a stair lift in their home, they’ll have to pay to have it removed, which is a high initial cost. They’ll likely look at other houses instead.

Takes up Stair Space

Many homes have relatively narrow stairways. Some also have steep stairways. Just getting up and down these stairwells under normal circumstances can feel challenging. When you add a stair lift, you narrow the existing space even more. You don’t want to be forced to squeeze yourself around a stair lift every day just to go to and from your bedroom.

That lack of space can also make it more difficult to do everyday tasks such as bringing in groceries or moving something from one floor to the other. The chair on the stair lift will get in the way.

Shop Home Elevators

If you’re trying to decide between a stair lift and a home elevator, the answer is probably clear to you now. You can receive more value, enjoy more versatility and get more return from a home elevator. And with so many options to choose from, you’re sure to find something that fits your house perfectly.

Are you ready to begin shopping? We have a selection of home elevators to suit your unique needs. We can discuss the best options for your home based on size, style and budget. Get in touch with us today by calling 800-343-9007 or filling out our online contact form. We look forward to helping you.